Filming for a Scene

A scene is made from pictures of something that holds still, taken while the camera moves round it. How good the scene is depends far more on those pictures than on any setting.

What makes a good capture

  • Move the camera; do not stand still and turn. The program measures depth from the camera changing place. A pan from one spot gives it nothing to measure, and it will say so.
  • Go all the way round if you want to see the subject from all the way round, and at more than one height if you can. Whatever was not filmed is guesswork in the scene.
  • Overlap generously. Each picture should share well over half of what it shows with the one before.
  • Keep it sharp and steady. Move slowly in good light. Lock the exposure and focus if the camera lets you.
  • Nothing should move. People walking through, leaves in the wind and passing cars become smears. A scene that moves needs several cameras at once.
  • Avoid glass, mirrors and bare walls where you can. Shiny and featureless surfaces give the program nothing to hold on to.

How many pictures

For a video, the program chooses for you: it keeps the sharpest frame of each short stretch, 200 in all unless you change Frames from a video. That number suits a clip of half a minute to a couple of minutes going once round a subject. A long or wandering clip deserves more, 300 to 400; more than that mostly costs time.

For photographs, think in the same range:

Subject Photographs, as a guide
A single object you can walk round 60 to 150
A building, a statue, a room 150 to 300
Something larger, or seen from several heights 300 and more

There is no fixed minimum, but the fewer the pictures, the more of the scene is guessed. Under about 50, expect holes and haze from any side that was not well covered. The still scenes on the website were made from 160 to 200 frames of video each.

More pictures are not always better: twice as many take about twice as long to place, and pictures that are nearly the same add little. What helps is coverage, new angles and heights, not repetition.

Does the order matter?

Not for the result. It matters for how the cameras are found, and you tell the program which you have with In shooting order in the Cameras section.

  • Ticked (the default): the pictures follow one another as they were taken, which a video's frames always do and a walk round with a stills camera usually does. Each picture is compared with the dozen after it and a few further on, which is quick, and the program also checks whether the end of the walk came back to the start. Order is read from the file names, the way a person reads them: IMG_9.jpg comes before IMG_10.jpg.
  • Unticked: the pictures are in no particular order, for instance gathered from several cameras or several visits. Each is compared more widely to find its neighbours. It takes longer and needs nothing from the names.

If you are not sure, leave it ticked for a video and untick it for a folder of photographs collected from different places. Ticking it for pictures that are not really in order is the one choice that can fail: neighbours in the list will not overlap, and too few cameras will be found.

When cameras cannot be found

The program says why in a sentence, and each picture it could not place carries its own reason. The usual causes:

  • The camera turned on the spot. Film again, walking.
  • Too little overlap. Fill in the gaps with more pictures.
  • Blur. From a video, ask for fewer frames so that only the sharpest are kept, or film again more slowly.
  • Two halves that never meet. A front and a back with nothing between them come out as two unrelated sets. Film the corner between them.

Footage that was already solved

A folder that another program has solved, a COLMAP workspace or a transforms.json, opens with its cameras, and Solve cameras is not needed. Methodox Splats keeps its own solve in a .splats folder inside your photograph folder, in the same layout, so the next time you open that folder the cameras are already there.